California Becomes First State to Ban Four Additives in Food

john william

Additives in Food

By banning four widely used food additives linked to numerous health risks, California has made history, marking a major step forward for public health and food safety. This initiative, pushed by Governor Gavin Newsom, has the potential to impact food consumption patterns across the country.

A Progressive Step Towards Safer Food

Red dye No. 3, potassium bromate, brominated vegetable oil, and propylparaben are the four ingredients in dispute. The FDA has not yet prohibited these additives despite the fact that the EU and other countries have done so due to concerns about their possible negative health effects. Governor Gavin Newsom said in a statement, “The additives addressed in this bill are already banned in various other countries.” Until the FDA conducts a nationwide evaluation and sets revised safety standards for certain chemicals, the law seeks to take action on them.

The Legislative Effort

Assembly member Jesse Gabriel introduced the bill that resulted to this historic shift, and Assembly member Buffy Wicks strongly supported it. It is important to note that the goal of this legislation is not to ban things like orange drink, hamburger rolls, and candies that contain these ingredients. To assure the safety of their products, producers must instead make little modifications to their ingredients.

Gabriel said with optimism, “We have incredible confidence that consumers are still going to be able to enjoy all the products that we know and love here in the United States, just without those harmful chemicals.” Brands will have plenty of time to adapt their formulas and create new safety standards for these ingredients before the law takes effect in 2027, if the FDA makes the necessary revisions.

A Voice for Consumer Protection

The Environmental Working Group, which does research and campaigning for the health of the public, has praised this action. It estimates that up to 12,000 items will have to have their components changed because of this. The organization’s mission, which includes promoting higher health and safety standards in the food industry, is consistent with this major change.

But it’s worth noting that the FDA has generally approved these chemicals for use in food. The department is now drafting a rule to revoke approval of brominated vegetable oil. The FDA rigorously reviews and controls food additives to make sure they are safe, according to a spokeswoman. This suggests that significant changes to FDA regulations may take a long time to implement.

Gabriel’s primary objective is clear: to protect the well-being of children, families, and consumers in California. However, there’s also a secondary objective at play. This move aims to send a powerful message to the FDA and the federal government, highlighting the urgent need for reform within the FDA’s regulatory process.

The Four Banned Additives

California has chosen to ban four additives, so let’s examine them in more detail.

·       Red Dye No. 3:

It’s used often in food coloring, and its potential health effects have sparked some alarm.

·       Potassium Bromate:

This ingredient, which is added to flour to increase the bread’s rise, has also been linked to health problems.

·       Brominated Vegetable Oil:

The health risks associated with this emulsifier’s use in citrus drinks have led to its restriction in some countries.

·       Propylparaben:

It’s a common food preservative that has been linked to endocrine disruption and other health problems.

Health hazards linked to these chemicals include cancer in laboratory animals, reproductive problems in animals, behavioral problems in children, and endocrine disruption. The state of California has taken a preventative measure by banning certain substances.

Mixed Reactions

Understandably, not everyone is on board with this change. Concerns have been voiced by the National Confectioners Association, which represents the confectionery industry. They say people won’t know what to believe about food safety if Governor Newsom signs the measure. They argue that instead of a unified national food safety system, this measure creates a hodgepodge of differing state standards that could drive up food prices.

But those who support the ban say that, in this day and age, when food safety and consumer health are of paramount importance, it is imperative that customers be shielded from potentially hazardous additives.


The state of California has taken a courageous step toward protecting the health and safety of its citizens by banning four contentious chemicals. California’s bold action sends a clear message to other states and the FDA about the importance of reconsidering food safety rules. Despite worries and pushback from some industries, the primary goal is still safeguarding consumers from any potential health dangers posed by these additives.


Will this ban affect the availability of food products in California?

In fact, the purpose of the prohibition is to get rid of the dangerous ingredients while still allowing the products to be sold with just minor component changes.

Are these additives banned in other countries?                

The European Union and other regions have prohibited certain compounds due to the health risks they pose.

How will manufacturers adapt to this ban?                                     

To meet the new standards, manufacturers will need to tweak some of their ingredients slightly.

When will this law go into effect?

The regulation won’t take effect until 2027, giving factories plenty of time to prepare.

Is the FDA planning to review the use of these additives nationally?

To reconsider the approval of brominated vegetable oil and maybe additional additives in food, the FDA is working on a proposed rule. This restriction in California highlights the necessity for federal reviews of this nature.

Leave a Comment